Blog post Part of special issue: Researching education and mental health: From ‘Where are we now?’ to ‘What next?’

Editorial: Researching education and mental health: From ‘Where are we now?’ to ‘What next?’

Michelle Jayman, Researcher/Lecturer at University of Roehampton Jonathan Glazzard, Rosalind Hollis Professor of Education for Social Justice at University of Hull Anthea Rose, Research Fellow at University of Lincoln 25 Feb 2020

The mental health and wellbeing of learners and teaching staff rank among some of the most pressing issues facing education as we enter a new decade. Growing rates of emotional distress among school-aged children, the impact of relentless workloads on teacher wellbeing, and the seismic effects of acute low-level funding and childhood poverty are common concerns. These were some of the critical areas for research attention highlighted at our special interest group’s inaugural conference – Researching education and mental health: Where are we now? – in July 2019. The event brought together researchers, academics and practitioners from contexts ranging from early years to higher education to discuss worries, deliberate practical solutions and set a dynamic research agenda moving forward. This special issue of the BERA Blog presents a collection of papers from the conference, and features groundbreaking projects supporting mental health and wellbeing in education as well as showcasing some of the latest studies to emerge, collectively, helping steer the 2020 research agenda in this crucial area.

‘The mental health and wellbeing of learners and teaching staff rank among some of the most pressing issues facing education as we enter a new decade.’

The range of selected articles starkly demonstrates how all-pervasive mental health and wellbeing concerns are across age groups and educational settings. In the first instalment of this two-part special issue, Paul Croll and Gaynor Atwood chart mental wellbeing from adolescence into early adulthood in their longitudinal study of young people in England. Sveta Mayer reports on the trailblazing Youth Mental Health First Aid (Youth MHFA) programme evaluation in schools, while Sarah Adams shares her research on the self-harm experiences of primary-aged children. Michelle Jayman and Annita Ventouris introduce Book of Beasties, an innovative mental wellness card game delivered in schools; and Josie Maitland discusses how the complexity of school systems influences whole-school approaches to promoting mental health in practice.

The second part of this special issue, which publishes on Tuesday, 3 March, looks at mental health and adult learners. First, Aimee Quickfall, Emma Clarke and Shaun Thompson and colleagues explore the workload and wellbeing of PGCE students through their education journey, while Siobhan Lynam, Caroline Lafarge, Raffaella Margherita Milani and Marcia Worrell highlight the experiences of postgraduate students from black, Asian and minority ethnic backgrounds. Richard Brock, Emma Towers, Alex Manning and Helen Damon give insight into new research on novel approaches to supporting teacher wellbeing, alongside Nicky Lambert, Alfonso Pezzella, Ruairi Mulhern and Jenny Phillips, who relate some creative ways to support students’ learning and boost resilience. Finally, Sinéad McBrearty shifts our attention to the wider social and political landscape, and puts the spotlight on major systemic issues which are critical to our understanding and response to mental health and wellbeing issues in education.

In the wake of the government’s mental health green paper (DHSC & DfE, 2017), the lens has focussed firmly on the role and responsibilities of schools to promote emotional health and develop a whole-school culture of wellbeing. This attention shows no sign of abating with the introduction of compulsory health education in the curriculum in England from September 2020 with a focus on how pupils of all ages can look after their mental wellbeing and the positive link between physical and mental health. These developments suggest the value of nurturing a child’s mental health as well as their academic potential has become more broadly recognised. Nonetheless, while the implementation of mental health interventions in schools is a welcome step forward, it is imperative that stretched resources are invested in evidence-based projects shown to make improvements to children’s wellbeing. Like schools, universities need to adopt a holistic, institution-wide approach; one which involves embedding mental health into the higher education curriculum and makes sure implementation decisions are based on the strength of the evidence.

Chronic mental health and wellbeing issues among teaching staff and trainees entering the profession have come resoundingly to the fore. Many educational professionals feel ill-equipped to manage escalating demands and competing priorities with additional strains and stressors becoming deleterious to their own wellbeing. Worryingly, presenteeism is evident when teachers continue to work due to unspoken pressure not to take time off. Research also suggests that teachers’ stress can be passed on to learners: primary-aged pupils of teachers with higher rates of self-reported ‘burnout’ were found to have elevated levels of the stress hormone cortisol (Oberle & Schonert-Reich, 2016), indicating a two-fold negative impact on wellbeing.

Supporting the mental health of children, young people and staff is clearly an urgent priority. Initial teacher training requires greater focus on how to support the mental health needs of students. Moreover, while reaching out to every child with a universal approach is important, this needs to be complemented by targeted services for children already displaying signs of difficulties. Embedding an institution-wide culture of wellbeing also involves staff exercising self-care in their practice and this requires a cultural sea change. In the current climate, prioritising teacher and student mental health seems to feature lower down on the strategic agenda than exercising performance reviews and boosting examination results.

While we recognise the pivotal role of education in supporting mental health and wellbeing for all, discourses of resilience and character education which place the onus on individuals and educational settings imply we can address mental health issues in a vacuum. This misconception is distracting and needs challenging; the lens shifted to the broader societal context, acknowledging the deep-rooted causes of mental ill health such as poverty, adverse childhood experiences, and academic-related pressures which emanate from wider political decisions such as the overhaul of the examinations system. Sufficient investment in timely and appropriate services to meet the needs of learners and staff once they have been identified is paramount. Beyond this, educationalists must unite in generating evidence-based research to prompt systemic transformation, helping foster a cultural shift that normalises and nurtures self-care for everyone.

References

Department of Health and Social Care [DHSC], & Department for Education [DfE]. (2017). Transforming children and young people’s mental health provision: A green paper. London. Retrieved from https://www.gov.uk/government/consultations/transforming-children-and-young-peoples-mental-health-provision-a-green-paper

Oberle, E., & Schonert-Reich, K. A. (2016). Stress contagion in the classroom? The link between classroom teacher burnout and morning cortisol in elementary school students. Social Science & Medicine, 159, 30–37.

Michelle Jayman, Dr

Researcher/Lecturer at University of Roehampton

Michelle Jayman is a developmental psychologist with a strong background in education and extensive work experience in schools. She is a Lecturer in Psychology at the University of Roehampton and a Champion for the British Psychological Society Education Section. Her main research interests include children’s and young people’s mental health and wellbeing, programmes and interventions to support and improve learner outcomes, and the relationship between technology and wellbeing.

Jonathan Glazzard, Professor

Rosalind Hollis Professor of Education for Social Justice at University of Hull

Jonathan Glazzard is the Rosalind Hollis Professor of Education for Social Justice at the University of Hull. He researches LGBTQ+, mental health, disability and early literacy. In 2018, he became co-convenor of the BERA SIG for Mental Health and Wellbeing in Education. Jonathan is a teacher educator and has extensive experience in leading primary ITE programmes and in ITE quality assurance across primary and secondary courses. He teaches on all education programmes and supervises students at masters and doctoral levels. He is a National Teaching Fellow and a Principal Fellow of the Higher Education Academy. He has recently completed his third doctorate in Education at the University of East Anglia.

Anthea Rose, Dr

Research Fellow at University of Lincoln

Anthea Rose is a research fellow at the Lincoln Academy of Learning and Teaching (LALT), University of Lincoln. She is currently leading the local Lincolnshire evaluation of the Uni Connect programme, funded by the Office for Students (OfS), which aims to raise the aspirations and attainment of students from disadvantaged backgrounds. Anthea specialises in qualitative research methods and has a particular interest in social justice and issues around equality, gender and the impact of government policy on education practices. Anthea is also a co-convenor of BERA’s Mental Health and Wellbeing Special Interest Group.