Blog post Part of special issue: Covid-19, education and educational research

Considering teacher wellbeing and commitment to teaching in the event of a ‘firebreak’ lockdown this autumn

Maxine Watkins, Research Fellow at University of Birmingham Alison Kington, Professor in Psychology of Education at University of Worcester Kathryn Spicksley, Research Fellow at University of Birmingham 29 Sep 2021

There are reports that an October lockdown might be used as a ‘firebreak’ if cases of the Covid-19 virus rise too high with the return of schools and universities (Mason & Davis, 2021). As emerging literature suggests that teachers and school leaders experienced increased levels of anxiety during the pandemic – leading some staff to consider leaving the profession altogether (see for example Presley, 2021) – this blogpost suggests that school leadership teams should focus on practices which not only encourage collaboration in school, but also offer opportunities for staff to develop and maintain strong relationships and collaborative working when teaching remotely.

In spring 2020, during the period when school buildings were closed (except to children of key workers and those who were considered to be vulnerable) and teaching activities moved online, we conducted interviews with 30 teachers working in primary and secondary schools across England. The interviews explored teachers’ experiences of teaching remotely, considering changes to their roles, along with any positive or challenging influences on personal and professional relationships. Transcripts were analysed using corpus-assisted discourse analysis, an emergent method in education research (Pérez-Paredes, 2020). Corpus-assisted discourse analysis involves inputting bodies of text into specialist computer software; this software analyses word frequencies and helps the researcher to identify patterns of vocabulary and grammar. As we were particularly interested in how teachers discursively constructed their relationship with peers – and how this influenced their perception of remote education and their sense of wellbeing – corpus-assisted discourse analysis helped us to identify discursive patterns across the corpora of interviews conducted.

It was interesting to find that teachers who felt a strong sense of connection with peers constructed a salient social identity – expressed through the use of the pronoun ‘we’ – and appeared to have experienced a positive transition to remote teaching:

‘We’re more than just a department of individual teachers, we’re a solid team who work well together, respect each other, learn from each other, and support each other.’
Tamara

‘I think we’ve stayed strong as a school, shared our expertise and remained confident in our ability to do the job we trained for [. . .] even in these strange times.’
Noah

In contrast, teachers who felt disconnected from peers constructed a salient individual identity – expressed by utterances of isolation or loneliness – and appeared to experience higher levels of stress and a reduced sense of professional identity:

‘Yes, it’s been very stressful from a professional point of view and a personal one. Professionally, I’ve found it hard to be isolated from the others and feel as if I’m missing out on things [. . .] It’s starting to affect the bond I used to feel with being a teacher.’
Susan

Furthermore, for some teachers in our study, feelings of isolation had prompted them to consider leaving teaching:

‘I’m thinking about leaving the profession, definitely about leaving the school at least. This has given me time to think about it without having to be with them every day.’ Robert

The findings from this study support previous discussions highlighting the importance of professional relationships and sense of connection for teachers (Spicksley & Watkins, 2020) along with broader literature within social psychology, suggesting that social connectedness and a sense of ‘we-ness’ leads to increased resilience and wellbeing (Jetten et al., 2017). These relationships and a sense of ‘we-ness’ should be considered as central to teachers’ wellbeing and resilience and to their commitment to the profession, not only when teaching in schools but, perhaps even more importantly, when teaching remotely.

This blog reflects on key findings from an article that was published in Frontiers in Psychology in August 2021. The full open access article is available here.

References

Jetten, J., Haslam, S. A., Cruwys, T., Greenaway, K. H., Haslam, C., & Steffens, N. K. (2017). Advancing the social identity approach to health and well‐being: Progressing the social cure research agenda. European Journal of Social Psychology, 47(7), 789–802. https://doi.org/10.1002/ejsp.2333

Mason, R., & Davis, M. (2021, September 7). No 10 not ruling out ‘firebreak’ lockdown if Covid cases rise. Guardian https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/sep/07/no-10-not-ruling-out-firebreak-lockdown-if-covid-cases-rise

Pérez-Paredes, P. (2020). Corpus linguistics for education: A guide for research. Routledge.

Pressley, T. (2021). Factors contributing to teacher burnout during COVID-19. Educational Researcher, 50(5). https://doi.org/10.3102/0013189X211004138

Spicksley, K., & Watkins, M. (2020). Early-career teacher relationships with peers and mentors: Exploring policy and practice. In A. Kington & K. Blackmore (Eds.), Social and Learning Relationships in Primary Schools (pp. 93–116). Bloomsbury.

Maxine Watkins, Dr

Research Fellow at University of Birmingham

Maxine Watkins has a keen interest in the social psychology of education and teaching. Her PhD took a grounded theory approach to explore the dynamic nature of a teacher professional identity and its relationship with career decisions and commitment to the profession. Analysis of life history and professional timeline interviews supported the development of a multidimensional, identity-based model of teacher career. Her model differentiates between multiple levels of identity (individual, relational, collective) and the relationship with different foci of commitment (career role, school community, shared ideology). Maxine was a lecturer in psychology within the School of Psychology at the University of Worcester between October 2018 to July 2021 and is now a research fellow in the School of Social Policy at the University of Birmingham.

Alison Kington, Professor

Professor in Psychology of Education at University of Worcester

Alison Kington is a professor in psychology of education at the University of Worcester. She has worked in a number of research and teaching roles, gaining extensive experience of designing and conducting mixed methods research in education and social psychology. Her research, which is cross-disciplinary in its theoretical and methodological approaches, focuses on the nature, quality and dynamics of educational relationships and identities, and she has a particular interest in the influence of teacher and pupil characteristics on social interactions within the classroom. Alison has published widely in relation to her substantive and methodological interests. She is on the editorial board of BERA’s Review of Education and a member of the BERA College of Reviewers.

Kathryn Spicksley, Dr

Research Fellow at University of Birmingham

Dr Kathryn Spicksley is a British Academy Postdoctoral Research Fellow at the University of Birmingham. Her postdoctoral project is concerned with developing a playful card game to improve dialogic mentoring between early career teachers and their mentors. Kathryn's PhD, titled New Faces and Changing Places: Discourse, identity and early-career primary teachers in post-2010 Multi-Academy Trusts, explored the relationship between post-2010 education policy and Early Career Teacher professional identity. It won the BERA Doctoral Thesis Prize in 2022. Kathryn is currently an editor of the BERA Blog.